The contested impact of cognitive linguistic research on the psycholinguistics of metaphor understanding
Problems with Cognitive Linguistic studies
What counts as a metaphor?
Some psychologists and linguists argue that many conventional expressions viewed as metaphorical by cognitive linguists are not metaphorical at all, and are treated by ordinary speakers/listeners as literal speech (Glucksberg 2001; Keysar, Shen, Glucksberg and Horton 2000). They suggest that simple expressions like “He was depressed” are entirely literal, and are not motivated by a conceptual metaphor such as SAD IS DOWN. Some empirical evidence suggests that people comprehend many conventional expressions without activating any metaphorical mappings or conceptual metaphors (Keysar et al. 2000).
How does one identify any instance of language as conveying metaphorical meaning? Conceptual metaphor theory lacks an explicit identification procedure capable of reliably identifying metaphorically-used words and expressions in discourse. Various scholars are now working on creating explicit, reliable criteria for doing just this (Barcelona 2002; Dirven 2002; Ruiz de Mendoza 2002; Steen 2002). At the same time, conceptual metaphor theory has no explicit method for identifying conceptual metaphors. How does one determine what constitutes adequate systematicity among linguistic expressions to be able to posit the existence of a conceptual metaphor? The cognitive linguistic logic seems circular. Analysts first examine linguistic expressions, enough so to infer the possible presence of underlying metaphorical mappings, and then test this possibility by referring back to language. But independent, nonlinguistic evidence is needed to break open the language-to-thought-to-language circle. Even if one does find systematicity in a set of expressions, how does one determine the actual source-to-target domain mappings, or metaphorical correspondences? These types of enduring questions are not particular to cognitive linguistics, as generative linguists face the same uncertainties in clearly identifying various syntactical patterns, to take one example.
The failure to provide reliable criteria for identifying metaphoric language and concepts suggests to many scholars that cognitive linguistic claims simply lack empirical support and should not be treated as either psychologically real (Glucksberg 2001; Murphy 1996) or philosophical (Haser 2005) accounts of metaphoric language and thought.