Discourse-Restricted Quantification
Side by side with the evidence suggested above, a further type of argument for multiple wh-displacement into the C domain in German comes from discourse restrictions. In this section, I present the relevant data and introduce a means to account for them, Discourse-Restricted Quantification (Grohmann 1998).
Compare, for example, the following two discourse contexts and the (in)felicity (marked with ‘‘a’’) of a multiple wh-question in English and German:
(1)


(2)

As these cases show, German allows a felicitous binary wh-question only if the set of individuals is part of the common ground between speaker and hearer, introduced in the discourse. The English example in (2a) is a perfectly reasonable question, and a potential answer would be something like (3).
(3)

This felicity requirement is captured by a condition I called, for better or worse, ‘‘Discourse-Restricted Quantification’’ in earlier work (Groh mann 1998).
(4)

In other words, DRQ requires the referents of all wh-phrases in a multiple wh-question to be salient to a certain degree. As the above contrasts show, it applies strictly to German, but not to English; this is the notion of top icality understood throughout.
What DRQ essentially expresses is the intuition that all wh-phrases in a German multiple wh-question must be D(iscourse)-linked (possibly, but not necessarily in the sense of Pesetsky 1987). While a wh-phrase in an information question represents a novel set of individuals (new information), the set of individuals represented by D-linked wh-phrases is to some degree known (old information). The term DRQ can be used to distinguish a condition of D-linking on all wh-phrases (in German), while D-linking simply applies to those elements commonly identified as such.